One of the major flaws with Oasis’ (“difficult”) third album, Be Here Now, was that most of the tracks seemed to be overblown rehashes of previous Oasis songs. That’s not just an impression you get, it’s also musically true. It’s worth noting here that the opening single, D’You Know What I Mean?, was essentially Wonderwall with distortion and a different chorus (musico-boffs – try the old F#m-A-E-B on both songs). Don’t Go Away’s chorus borrows equally heavily from Whatever. Then again it’s not as if they hadn’t already lifted the E-G#-C#m-A used on both Digsy’s Dinner and Married With Children in order to make She’s Electric on their second album. The less said about the fourth and fifth albums the better.
Now, if you hadn’t noticed, Coldplay released an album earlier this year entitled X&Y. When I first heard the opening bars of Speed of Sound on the radio, I thought to myself (with unwitting intelligence, as it turns out) “hey, someone’s completely ripped off Coldplay”. A few seconds later, when the vocals cut in, “Oh. Wait.” Here’s the science: the chord steps underlying that piano intro are precisely the same ones underlying the piano intro on Clocks, an incredibly successful single from their second album. I’m not saying the two songs are the same – they may have been clever enough to shift the entire pattern up or down a tone or two, unlike Oasis who just play exactly the same chords - but there’s a suspicious similarity.
So out comes the second single, Fix You. And blow me down with a feather duster if it, in turn, is not a complete rip-off of The Scientist, a different incredibly successful single from their second album. Don’t get me going on the Am-F-C-G thing. I’ve lost count of how many songs have become popular in the last ten years on that chord pattern.*
I haven’t bought X&Y. If there’s a song on there that sounds like In My Place, we can assume it will be the next single.
Like football managers bringing in established foreigners rather than nurturing and developing young talent, the music industry continues to play the safe bet – oh look, Am-F-C-G works, it pleases the ear of the average listener, so we’ll just churn out song after song after song. Does anyone want to try and make a successful song from something other than four-chord blocks (one minor, three major, like you wanted sir)? Something other than bars of 4/4 grouped in multiples of four? And hell, can anyone release a boyband powerballad without transposing up one tone for the final chorus?
*Am-F-C-G, the corporate chord pattern. For reference: The Passenger, Iggy Pop; Save Tonight, Eagle Eye Cherry; The Kids Aren’t Alright, Offspring; Glorious, Andreas Johnson; Otherside, Red Hot Chili Peppers; Wherever, Whenever, Shakira; The Scientist, Coldplay; The Space Between, Tracy Chapman; Zombie, The Cranberries; Listen To Your Heart, DHT; One Of Us, Joan Osborne; Complicated, Avril Lavigne; Jeune et con, Saez; Dernière danse, Kyo; Une seule vie, Elle danse seule, AND Au paradis, Gerald frigging de Palmas; Tieni il Tempo, 883; and countless countless others, whether in Am or transposed. Google it and you’ll find hit songs from Russia, Brazil, Finland, Spain, Israel, Iceland…